.22.png)
Is nearly half of Michigan living paycheck to paycheck? It may sound shocking, but new data suggest exactly that. Across the state, from the quiet shores of Lake County to the busy streets of Detroit, a huge number of families are struggling just to cover the basics each month. In fact, 41% of Michigan households couldn’t afford all their basic needs in 2023 – meaning they either live below the poverty line or fall into the ALICE category (Asset Limited, Income Constrained, Employed). In plain English, these are our neighbors who are working hard yet still barely scraping by. This report breaks down where in Michigan families are most financially stretched, why it’s happening, and what it means for our communities. Written in the voice of a lifelong Michigander and Metro Detroit real estate expert, we’ll dive into the local trends behind the numbers – from rural counties Up North to the suburbs of Metro Detroit – in a conversational way. Let’s explore which Michigan counties have the most households living paycheck to paycheck, and why it matters to all of us.
Even with financial challenges, Michigan is still one of the best states for affordable starter homes, making it an ideal entry point for first-time buyers.
Understanding ALICE: A New Look at Financial Hardship in Michigan
Before we get into the county-by-county breakdown, it’s important to understand what “ALICE” means and why it matters. ALICE stands for Asset Limited, Income Constrained, Employed – essentially, working folks who earn above the official poverty line but still don’t make enough to afford life’s essentials. Think of the barista making $15/hour, the retail manager, the home health aide – they might not count as “in poverty” by federal definitions, yet their paychecks fall short of covering basic living costs. United Way and its research partners use the ALICE measure to get a more realistic picture of financial hardship in our communities than the outdated federal poverty stats.
How is ALICE different from the poverty line? The federal poverty line is very low – in 2023 it was set at $14,580 annual income for a single adult, or $30,000 for a family of four. Try living on that, especially in a higher-cost area of Michigan! United Way’s Household Survival Budget, on the other hand, tallies up the actual minimum cost of living for each county. This includes necessities like housing, child care, food, transportation, health care, phone and internet, plus taxes. Statewide, the average minimum budget in 2023 came out to $28,740 a year for a single adult, and about $74,500 for a family of four – more than double the federal poverty thresholds. That gap shows why the poverty rate alone (which counted 14% of Michigan households in 2023) misses a lot of families who aren’t officially “poor” but are definitely one unexpected bill away from crisis.
In short, ALICE households are the working poor – your child’s daycare teacher, the nursing aide at the local clinic, the cashier at Kroger. They earn too much to qualify for many assistance programs, but not enough to build savings or get ahead. They’re living paycheck to paycheck, often without any safety net. By looking at ALICE data, we can see where families are truly struggling to stay afloat in Michigan, beyond what traditional poverty stats show.
2 in 5 Michigan Households Struggle to Afford the Basics
Statewide, the numbers are eye-opening. Out of Michigan’s approximately 4.08 million households, 41% were below the ALICE Threshold in 2023. That’s about 1.67 million households who couldn’t meet their basic monthly expenses. This 41% is composed of two groups: those in outright poverty (14% of households) and those in the ALICE category (27%). Put another way, about 2 out of every 5 Michigan families live paycheck to paycheck, struggling to cover essentials like rent, groceries, childcare, and utilities.
To clarify this breakdown, here are the key statewide figures from the United For ALICE report:
14% of Michigan households earned below the Federal Poverty Level (in 2023, under $14.6k for a single adult or $30k for a family of four). These families are officially poor by government standards.
27% of Michigan households were ALICE households – meaning they earned above the poverty line but below the ALICE survival budget for their county. They have income coming in, yet it’s not enough to afford all basic needs.
41% combined were below the ALICE Threshold, i.e. living paycheck to paycheck with income insufficient for the basics. (This 41% includes both the ALICE group and those in poverty.)
It’s staggering to realize that nearly half of the families in our state are essentially one emergency away from financial turmoil. To give that some perspective, the share of households struggling in Michigan has grown in recent years. The ALICE population tends to swell during tough economic times (like after the Great Recession and during the pandemic) and hasn’t fully receded. In fact, from 2019 to 2023, the number of Michigan households below the ALICE Threshold grew by over 100,000. United Way researchers noted that the last couple of years have seen the highest rates of hardship in the history of the ALICE study, indicating that despite low unemployment, a lot of working families are still on shaky ground. While the number of households in poverty has actually ticked down over the past decade, the ranks of ALICE families have risen – meaning many who climbed above poverty are still far from financially secure. It’s a reality check that Michigan’s economic recovery hasn’t reached everyone equally.
Where Are Families Struggling Most? Hardship by County
Financial hardship isn’t evenly spread across Michigan – some counties are far worse off than others. The ALICE report provides a county-by-county breakdown, and it reveals dramatic variations often masked by statewide averages. Generally, rural northern counties and certain urban centers have higher shares of struggling households, while some suburban counties show lower rates. Let’s unpack the extremes:
Counties with the Highest “Paycheck-to-Paycheck” Rates: According to the 2023 ALICE data, four Michigan counties stand out with over half of their households unable to afford basic needs. These are Clare County, Lake County, Iosco County, and Wayne County. In each of these counties, more than 50% of households are below the ALICE Threshold, meaning a majority of families live paycheck to paycheck. It’s a sobering statistic. It might not surprise folks that Wayne County – home to Detroit – is on this list, given the city’s well-documented economic challenges. But some of the others are more rural: Clare, Lake, and Iosco are smaller counties (in mid/northern Michigan) with high poverty and lower median incomes, which pushes their ALICE rates above 50%. In fact, a recent analysis noted that in a number of Michigan counties (including Wayne), more than half of all households are struggling to maintain a basic “survival budget”. That’s a majority of families in those areas living on the edge financially.
For context, Wayne County’s hardship is largely driven by the city of Detroit, where around two-thirds of households live in poverty or ALICE status. But even outside Detroit, parts of Wayne (like older inner-ring suburbs) have many working-class residents barely getting by. Meanwhile, counties like Clare or Lake are rural with limited industry and high unemployment, leading to persistent poverty. It’s striking that whether urban or rural, the result is similar: lots of families can’t make ends meet.
On the flip side, several affluent Michigan counties show much lower levels of financial hardship. For example, Oakland County (a suburban Detroit county known for affluent communities and a strong job base) has a significantly smaller share of ALICE households than Wayne. So do Washtenaw County (home to Ann Arbor and the University of Michigan) and Ottawa County (a relatively prosperous area on the west side). In these better-off counties, perhaps 1 in 4 or 1 in 3 households struggle, versus 1 in 2 in the hardest-hit counties. That’s still a lot, but comparatively less dire.
However, even within wealthy counties, there are pockets of need. The data drills down further to the city and township level, showing that some communities are in much tougher shape than others, even if they’re in the same county.
.png)
City Spotlight: Communities Living on the Edge (and Those Doing Well)
Zooming in, the ALICE report highlighted specific cities and townships (with at least 1,000 households) that have extreme levels of hardship. The top five Michigan communities with the highest percentages of households living paycheck to paycheck are eye-opening:
- Royal Oak Charter Township (Oakland County) – 78% of households at ALICE or poverty level
- Highland Park (Wayne County) – 76% of households at ALICE or below
- Benton Harbor (Berrien County) – 76% struggling households
- River Rouge (Wayne County) – 74% struggling households
- Muskegon Heights (Muskegon County) – 73% struggling households
These places are mostly urban or industrial communities that have faced economic decline. For instance, Highland Park (enclave within Detroit) and River Rouge (downriver Detroit area) have long histories of disinvestment and high poverty. Benton Harbor, on Lake Michigan, has struggled since manufacturing jobs left. Muskegon Heights is a small city with many low-income families. And Royal Oak Township – not to be confused with the affluent City of Royal Oak – is a tiny, historically Black township in Oakland County that has very few households but extremely high poverty. In these communities, roughly 3 out of 4 families are barely scraping by, which is an astounding figure.
Now compare that to the top five communities with the lowest share of struggling households (again, among those with 1,000+ households):
- Huntington Woods (Oakland County) – only 10% of households at ALICE or poverty
- Ada Township (Kent County) – 10% of households struggling
- East Grand Rapids (Kent County) – 11% struggling households
- Southfield Township (Oakland County) – 12% struggling households
- Oakland Charter Township (Oakland County) – 13% struggling households
These places are some of the most affluent in Michigan. For example, Huntington Woods (near the Detroit Zoo) is a high-income bedroom community; East Grand Rapids and Ada Township are wealthy suburbs of Grand Rapids; Oakland Twp and Southfield Twp encompass upscale neighborhoods in Oakland County. In such communities, 9 out of 10 households are doing well enough to be above the ALICE threshold, and only a small fraction live paycheck to paycheck. These areas boast higher incomes, often professional residents, and far less poverty – essentially the opposite end of the spectrum from the cities listed earlier.
Figure: Michigan Communities at the Extremes, 2023 – This chart compares the five cities/townships with the highest rates of financial hardship (left, in red) to the five with the lowest rates (right, in green). “Financial hardship” here means households living at or below the ALICE Threshold (including poverty). As shown, places like Royal Oak Charter Twp, Highland Park, and Benton Harbor have over 70% of households struggling, whereas affluent enclaves like Huntington Woods or Ada Twp have around 10%. Such a stark contrast underscores the deep economic disparities between different Michigan communities. Even in wealthy counties, there can be small pockets with high need – and vice versa.
What do these extremes tell us? For one, Metro Detroit exhibits both ends of the spectrum – from struggling inner-city areas to affluent suburbs – often just a few miles apart. It also shows how local economies and history shape financial outcomes. Communities that lost major employers or suffer from systemic disinvestment (like Highland Park or Benton Harbor) unsurprisingly have more ALICE households. Meanwhile, communities with high property values, good schools, and thriving industries (like East Grand Rapids or Oakland Township) have far fewer families in financial distress.
For a family considering where to live in Michigan, these differences might influence their decision. Some may seek out areas with better economic opportunities or lower living costs. However, it’s worth noting that even the most prosperous areas aren’t immune from financial hardship – even 10% struggling means some neighbors are feeling the squeeze (perhaps fixed-income seniors or single-income households). And on the other side, places with very high ALICE rates often foster tight-knit communities working hard to uplift each other, despite widespread hardship.
Why Are So Many Michiganders Living Paycheck to Paycheck?
With such startling statistics, the natural question is why. What’s driving this widespread financial hardship across Michigan? The ALICE report and local experts point to a combination of factors that have converged:
Stagnant Low-End Wages: A huge share of Michigan’s common jobs simply don’t pay enough to live on. Out of the 20 most common occupations in the state (think retail salespersons, food prep workers, cashiers, etc.), 14 of them paid less than $20 per hour in 2023. Many pay around the minimum wage or only a bit above it. At the same time, full-time at $20/hour comes out to about $41,600 a year – which is still below the ALICE survival budget for a family in most counties. In fact, the report found 30% of all workers in those top 20 jobs lived in households below the ALICE Threshold. In short, lots of working people earn poverty-level wages. Michigan’s job market, while improving in unemployment numbers, still leans heavily on service and care sector jobs that don’t provide a sufficient income to meet rising costs. It’s hard to get ahead when your paycheck won’t cover rent and childcare and groceries each month.
Rising Costs of Essentials (Inflation Bite): The past few years have seen the cost of living skyrocket, driven by inflation in essentials. We’re talking double-digit jumps in prices for things like food, fuel, and utilities in 2022, and continued inflation in 2023. Even though the official inflation rate has eased somewhat, the damage was done: household budgets were squeezed from all sides. Wages did go up for many workers post-pandemic, but not as fast as the cost of basic necessities. ALICE families, who already had no wiggle room, got hit especially hard by expensive groceries and gas. The ALICE report noted, for example, that basic expenses in the Midwest rose about 10.3% from 2021 to 2022, and another ~5.8% in 2023 – outpacing average income gains. Every extra dollar to keep the heat on or put food on the table is a dollar not going into savings (if they had any to begin with).
Housing Affordability Crisis: A big driver of financial stress is housing costs – both rent and home prices. Michigan, like much of the country, experienced a surge in housing costs. According to data cited by MLive, the median rent for a one-bedroom apartment in Michigan jumped nearly $250 in just three years (from about $1,116 in May 2020 to $1,367 by May 2023). That’s a significant increase for someone on a tight budget. Statewide, median rents rose almost 9% in 2022 alone, one of the highest increases in the nation. We’ve also seen home prices climb in many markets, including Metro Detroit, during the pandemic housing boom. So whether an ALICE household rents or tries to own, they’re facing higher monthly payments. Housing is typically the biggest expense in the Household Survival Budget, and when rent or mortgage eats up 40-50% of your income, it leaves little for anything else. Michigan’s older cities (like Detroit, Flint, Saginaw) also have many homes in disrepair; families might spend extra on utilities due to poor insulation, etc., or face big repair bills if they own. In short, the cost of keeping a roof overhead is a major challenge.
Child Care and Other Necessities: For working parents, child care is often as expensive as a second rent. The ALICE budget includes child care costs, which for a Michigan family with two young kids can run nearly $1,100/month (if both kids need full-time care). Imagine making $15/hour (~$2,600 a month before taxes) and trying to pay $1,100 in childcare – it’s untenable without trade-offs. Many ALICE families have to make hard choices: maybe one parent quits work because child care costs more than they earn, or they rely on a patchwork of relatives and subsidized programs (if available). Other essentials like healthcare and transportation are also burdens. Michigan is a state where you often need a car to get to work, so gas prices and car repairs hit working poor families hard. These costs rising faster than wages is a key reason so many people are on the brink.
End of Pandemic Supports: During 2020-2021, various temporary supports (stimulus checks, expanded unemployment, Child Tax Credit, extra food assistance, eviction moratoriums, etc.) provided a lifeline that briefly helped reduce financial stress for many. But by 2023, most of those pandemic-era aid programs expired, and the rug was effectively pulled out from under ALICE families. For example, the expanded Child Tax Credit had been giving families hundreds of dollars per month in 2021, which ended and wasn’t renewed. United Way researchers calculated that in 2022, a Michigan family of four with two small children received about $15,000 less in combined federal tax credits and stimulus payments compared to the previous year. That is a huge loss of income support. So even if paychecks grew a bit, the expiration of aid meant many households actually felt worse off in 2022-2023. As one United Way official put it, higher wages helped “a little,” but inflation plus the loss of pandemic supports kept ALICE households trapped in hardship. It was like running up a down escalator.
All these factors together create a perfect storm for Michigan’s ALICE population. It’s not just one thing – it’s a combo of low wages, high costs, and insufficient support systems. As a result, millions of Michiganders are working hard yet remain on the financial fringe. This has broader consequences: for instance, when people live paycheck to paycheck, they can’t save for emergencies or retirement, they delay healthcare, and they certainly aren’t out shopping for new homes or cars – which can dampen local economies. It also puts strain on social services and nonprofits that try to fill the gaps.
A Local Perspective: How This Affects Metro Detroit Families
As Metro Detroiters, we see these trends play out in our own backyard. Detroit’s high ALICE rate (around two-thirds of households) is a big piece of the statewide picture. Many families in the city are working low-wage jobs in retail, hospitality, or gig work without benefits. It’s common to hear of Detroit parents working 10-12 hour days between multiple jobs, yet still struggling to keep the lights on. The human side of the ALICE statistics is evident in things like long lines at local food banks or the fact that Detroit’s public schools qualify for universal free lunch because so many students come from low-income households.
In the Metro Detroit suburbs, the ALICE story is more mixed but still present. Take Oakland County: overall it’s relatively affluent, yet it contains pockets like Pontiac (65% ALICE/poverty) or Royal Oak Twp (78%) that have very high hardship rates. Meanwhile, just a few miles away you have Bloomfield Hills or Troy where the median income is much higher and ALICE rates are low. This close proximity of wealth and struggle is part of Metro Detroit’s landscape. It’s not unusual here to have one community with multi-million dollar homes and another nearby where a majority rent and live paycheck to paycheck. Local experts often talk about Metro Detroit’s “two economies.”
One real-world example: Highland Park, nestled inside Detroit, has about three-quarters of households struggling. Drive 15 minutes north and you’re in Birmingham, where upscale boutiques line the streets and ALICE is almost nonexistent. For families, that can mean starkly different experiences – in one, kids might worry about having enough food at home, while in the other, they’re enrolling in private swim lessons. As a Metro Detroit real estate team, we’ve seen how these economic divides influence housing choices. Some families feeling the squeeze in inner-city neighborhoods aim to move to areas with better job access or schools, but then face higher housing costs in those areas – it’s a Catch-22. Conversely, some folks in pricey suburbs who hit hard times may downsize or relocate to more affordable communities, even if it means a longer commute.
The ALICE data also highlight an aging population aspect. Notice that statewide, about 51% of senior (65+) households in Michigan are below the ALICE threshold. In Metro Detroit, we definitely see senior homeowners on fixed incomes struggling to pay ever-rising property taxes, medical bills, and upkeep. They might be house-rich but cash-poor, essentially living paycheck to paycheck on Social Security. Some end up selling longtime homes because they can’t afford maintenance – adding more housing supply to the market, but also signaling a personal hardship.
On the brighter side, Metro Detroit has a strong network of community organizations, churches, and initiatives aimed at helping ALICE families. From United Way’s 2-1-1 helpline to local food assistance programs and housing counseling, there is support out there – though demand often exceeds supply. We’ve also seen policy responses: for instance, Michigan recently expanded its Earned Income Tax Credit (EITC) from 6% to 30% of the federal credit, which beginning in the 2022 tax year put more refund money back into the pockets of low-income working families. Moves like that, along with proposals to assist with child care costs, show that lawmakers are starting to acknowledge ALICE families’ struggles.
The Cost of Basics vs. Wages: A Daily Juggle
It’s worth emphasizing the core math problem many Michiganders face: household costs have outpaced wages in many sectors. The ALICE “Household Survival Budget” for each county illustrates this. For example, in Wayne County, the cost for a family of four might be slightly different than in Oakland County or Grand Traverse County, but in every county the minimum budget far exceeds the federal poverty line. Wages at the lower end just haven’t kept up. Fourteen of the 20 most common jobs in Michigan (think retail, food service, admin assistants, factory jobs, etc.) pay under $20/hour, and many pay closer to $12-15/hour. Meanwhile, basics like housing and healthcare march upward in price each year. As a result, even a couple both working full-time at, say, $15/hour each (about $62,000 combined before taxes) can find themselves in an ALICE situation if they have kids or high expenses. By the time they pay rent (or a mortgage), car loans, gas, groceries, child care, and other bills, there’s nothing left – maybe even a shortfall that leads to credit card debt.
We often talk to young families in Metro Detroit who are dual-income but still can’t seem to save a down payment for a house. Many times it’s because their pay is just covering their monthly expenses with no cushion. They’re not overspending on luxuries; the basics are just that expensive relative to their income. This is the ALICE conundrum: you can be above poverty – even making $50k or $60k as a household – and yet not have any breathing room financially. It’s one reason why we see a lot of first-time homebuyers needing down payment assistance or gifts from family to make homeownership possible. Otherwise, they’re stuck renting and often paying more in rent than a mortgage would be, but they can’t save enough to break that cycle.
Another aspect is debt. When one lives paycheck to paycheck, any disruption (like a car breakdown or medical emergency) often leads to debt – whether credit card balances, payday loans, or borrowing from relatives. That debt then becomes another monthly expense (interest payments), adding to the burden. It’s easy to see how families can get trapped. Some ALICE households end up with poor credit due to missed payments, which then makes things like car insurance and financing more expensive – a vicious cycle.
Between that assistance and tools like the MI Home Loan and first-time buyer programs, many ALICE families are finding a clear path to purchase.
.png)
What This Means for Michigan Communities (and the Housing Market)
The prevalence of ALICE households has ripple effects. Communities with high financial hardship often struggle with lower consumer spending (families are buying necessities only), which can hurt local businesses. There’s also increased demand for public assistance, food pantries, and affordable housing programs. For instance, a city like Detroit has thousands on waitlists for housing vouchers or subsidized housing. High ALICE rates can also impact school districts – kids from financially stressed homes may need extra support or may move frequently as their parents chase affordable rent, affecting school stability.
From a real estate perspective, Michigan’s housing market reflects these economic divides. In areas with many ALICE households, we often see lower homeownership rates – simply because people can’t afford down payments or don’t qualify for mortgages. These are places where rental markets dominate, and investors might buy up cheaper properties to rent out (which can be both a challenge and an opportunity for the community). In contrast, wealthier areas with low ALICE percentages have higher homeownership and more stable home values, but even there, entry-level buyers might find limited affordable options.
One interesting trend is how migration within Michigan might be influenced. If living in, say, metro Detroit proper becomes too costly or challenging, some families may relocate to less expensive regions of Michigan (or out of state entirely). We’ve heard of folks moving from high-cost areas like Ann Arbor or Oakland County to more affordable ones like Genesee County or even out to the Thumb, seeking lower housing costs. However, if they move to a rural county, wages might drop too, so it’s a tough trade-off.
For communities trying to attract residents (like many smaller Michigan towns), being affordable is a selling point, but if jobs don’t pay much, newcomers might still face ALICE conditions. It’s a balancing act for economic developers: they need to lure jobs that pay living wages and keep housing reasonably priced to truly improve ALICE numbers.
New statewide programs like the $25K down payment assistance for first-generation buyers offer real hope for ALICE families ready to take the leap into homeownership.
Building a More Financially Secure Michigan
The ALICE report is a wake-up call. When 4 in 10 households statewide are barely staying afloat, it’s not just a them problem – it affects all of us. These are our coworkers, our children’s teachers, the small business owners down the street, the nurse’s aide caring for our grandparents. Michigan’s economy cannot thrive when such a large share of families are struggling. As the report emphasizes, this is not a small or new problem, and it won’t fix itself. But knowing the scope and the specifics (which counties, which groups are most affected) helps target solutions.
On the policy side, there are efforts underway to ease the burden. Beyond the EITC expansion, Michigan has also been looking at things like childcare tax credits, affordable housing initiatives, and increasing the minimum wage (there’s been debate about a $15 or higher minimum wage, which could lift some workers closer to the ALICE threshold). At the community level, organizations like United Way’s ALICE project are working to raise awareness and drive collaborations to tackle issues like affordable childcare, public transit, and job training. Even businesses are taking note – some larger employers in Michigan have started increasing wages or offering more flexible schedules, recognizing that financially stressed employees can’t be productive workers in the long run.
From a personal perspective, if you’re reading this as someone who feels caught in that paycheck-to-paycheck grind, know that you’re far from alone and there are resources that might help. Every county has agencies and non-profits geared toward financial counseling, utility assistance, or food support to lighten the load. Sometimes a small boost (like a utility grant or childcare scholarship) can free up enough money to start an emergency fund or pay off a high-interest debt, which can be a tipping point toward stability.
At The Perna Team, we believe in the importance of financial wellness as part of the path to homeownership and community stability. We’ve helped clients navigate various programs for first-time homebuyers and pointed them toward local resources when budgets are tight. Our experience as a Metro Detroit real estate team has shown us that knowledge is power – understanding market trends, knowing which areas are more affordable, and creative budgeting can open doors (literally) for families who thought homeownership was out of reach. For instance, exploring cities or neighborhoods with lower taxes or getting pre-qualified for down payment assistance can make a huge difference.
Michigan’s ALICE report shines a light on where families are struggling to stay afloat. It’s a call to action for all of us – community leaders, businesses, and neighbors alike – to invest in solutions that lift up our working families. When nearly half of our households are on the financial edge, the stability of our entire state is at stake. By understanding the challenges and working together on creative answers, we can move toward a future where fewer Michiganders are living paycheck to paycheck, and more can achieve the security of a stable, thriving home. When ALICE households prosper, Michigan prospers – and that’s something worth working for.
DON'T KEEP US A SECRET - SHARE WITH A FRIEND OR ON SOCIAL MEDIA!
THINKING OF MOVING TO Metro Detroit, OR LOOKING TO RELOCATE IN THE AREA? VIEW A LIST OF CURRENT HOMES FOR SALE BELOW.
Metro Detroit Homes for Sale
The Perna Team and Michael Perna are the best real estate agents in Metro Detroit and Ann Arbor. The Perna Team and Michael Perna have been hired as a real estate agent by hundreds of home owners to sell their homes in Metro Detroit and Ann Arbor.
The Perna Team were great to work with, and we’d absolutely recommend them to anyone buying a home in Metro Detroit. I even asked for a few of her business cards in case I run into someone who needs a realtor. Thanks again for everything!
Posted by Michael Perna on
Leave A Comment