.42.png)
It’s a crisp Saturday morning in downtown Birmingham, Michigan. You step out of Birmingham Place, the city’s iconic high-rise condo building on Old Woodward, and stroll to grab a latte from a cozy cafe near Shain Park. Living here has undeniable charm, walkable streets, upscale boutiques, top-notch restaurants. But as you sip your coffee, a practical question comes to mind: Is it actually cheaper to rent a condo here than to own one in 2025?
That rent-versus-own dilemma is on a lot of Metro Detroit minds lately, and for good reason. After all, home prices are up and mortgage rates aren’t what they used to be. Many lifelong Michiganders grew up hearing that owning a home is always the smart move, the classic “American Dream” our parents and grandparents swore by. Yet in today’s climate, even some seasoned locals are rethinking that advice. In a place like Birmingham, where condos like Birmingham Place offer luxury living in the heart of town, deciding whether to rent or buy isn’t as clear-cut as it once was. Let’s dive into the details with a friendly, knowledgeable look at the costs, lifestyle, and local trends, all from the perspective of a neighbor who knows Metro Detroit real estate inside and out.
The 2025 Rent vs. Buy Dilemma in Birmingham
Why is now such a tricky time for the rent-or-own decision? A big part of it comes down to the numbers in 2025. Across the U.S., and even here in Southeast Michigan, renting has in many cases become cheaper per month than owning. High interest rates and rising property values have pushed typical mortgage payments above the cost of renting in a lot of markets. In fact, according to recent studies, the average monthly mortgage payment nationwide is significantly higher than the average rent, and while Metro Detroit has one of the smallest gaps (only around a 2% difference in costs between owning and renting on average), that gap has still grown compared to a few years back.
Think about it: just a few years ago, mortgage rates were at record lows (remember those ~3% rates in 2021?). Buying was relatively affordable and monthly payments often beat out rents. But fast-forward to 2025, and rates have hovered in the 6–7% range for a 30-year loan. Home prices in Metro Detroit have climbed quickly too, some reports noted the median sale price jumped by six figures from 2023 to 2024 alone. Birmingham, being a highly sought-after community with excellent schools and amenities, saw its own share of price growth. The result is that owning a home or condo in Birmingham now costs more per month than it used to, while rents have also risen but at a steadier pace.
For Birmingham Place specifically, this means prospective residents are doing some careful math. This 10-story luxury condominium, built in the 1980s but updated with modern amenities, has units that appeal to downsizing empty-nesters, young professionals, and even small families who want an urban lifestyle in the suburbs. If you’re eyeing a condo here, you might find yourself asking: “Do I stretch for a mortgage, or do I rent and save a little each month?” To answer that, we need to compare the actual costs side by side.
Birmingham Place at a Glance: Homeownership Costs vs. Rent
Birmingham Place isn’t just any building, it’s the downtown Birmingham condo address, complete with concierge service, a rooftop deck, secure parking, and gleaming lobbies. Those perks come at a price, whether you rent or buy. Let’s break down a typical scenario in 2025 for a Birmingham Place condo:
- Condo Purchase Price (2025): Units for sale in Birmingham Place have ranged roughly from the mid-$300,000s for a one-bedroom up to $600,000 or more for larger two-bedroom units (and even around $1 million for a rare three-bedroom penthouse). For our example, imagine a 1-bedroom condo listed at about $350,000, a realistic ballpark for a nice unit in this building.
- Monthly Mortgage Payment: If you put 20% down (around $70k) on that $350k condo, you’d finance ~$280,000. At current interest rates (around 6.5% for a 30-year fixed loan in late 2025), the mortgage payment comes out to roughly $1,700 per month for principal and interest. Keep in mind, rates have been fluctuating; if you snag a rate closer to 6% it might be about $1,600, but at 7% it could be $1,750+. The trend has been a slight dip in rates toward the end of 2025, but we’re still far from those 3% days.
- Property Taxes: Birmingham’s property taxes are on the higher side (reflecting the premium of living in a top-tier city with great services and schools). As a homeowner living in your unit (qualifying for Michigan’s homestead exemption which gives owner-occupants a lower tax rate), you might pay roughly 1.5% of the condo’s value annually in taxes. On a $350,000 condo, that’s about $5,000 per year, or roughly $420 per month. (If that condo is an investment or second home, taxes would be higher, but we’ll assume you’d live in it as your primary residence.)
- HOA Fees: Birmingham Place, like most condos, charges a monthly homeowners association fee. This covers building maintenance, amenities, water, trash, and things like snow removal (a must in Michigan winters!). The HOA fee for a unit here averages around $500–$600 per month. Let’s peg it at $550 for our scenario. This ensures you don’t have to worry about mowing lawns or fixing the roof, but it’s a cost owners have that renters indirectly pay through rent.
- Homeowners Insurance & Utilities: Condo owners need an insurance policy for the interior of their unit (the HOA covers the building structure insurance). This might be relatively modest, say $30–$50 a month. And both owners and renters will pay personal utilities like electricity, gas, or internet separately. We’ll set these aside in the comparison since they’re similar whether you own or rent.
Now, add those up for the owner’s monthly outlay: roughly $1,700 (mortgage) + $420 (taxes) + $550 (HOA) + $40 (insurance). That’s about $2,710 per month. Give or take a bit, an owner of a $350k condo in Birmingham Place is looking at roughly $2,700+ each month in housing costs in 2025, after making that hefty down payment upfront.
What about renting the same place? Birmingham Place condos frequently pop up as rentals. In 2025, rent prices in the building range widely depending on unit size, floor level, and how updated the interior is. A one-bedroom can start around $2,100–$2,300 per month for, say, ~700 square feet. Some particularly upscale or larger units (two-bedrooms, high-floor with great views, designer finishes) have been listed for $4,000–$5,000+ per month. But let’s compare apples to apples: that one-bedroom condo we priced out for buying (around 615–700 sq ft) would likely rent for roughly $2,200–$2,400 a month in the current market.
So, monthly rent: $2,300 versus monthly ownership cost: $2,700 for the same unit. By this simple math, renting could save around $400–$500 per month in cash flow. Not a trivial difference! It’s clear why the question “Is renting cheaper?” is coming up, at first glance, yes, renting that Birmingham Place condo is cheaper month-to-month in 2025.
However, before you declare renting the winner, remember that monthly cost isn’t the whole story. Part of that $2,700 ownership cost is building equity for you. For instance, out of that $1,700 mortgage payment, a few hundred dollars (in the early years) actually goes toward paying down your principal loan balance, effectively a form of savings. Plus, homeowners potentially benefit if the property value rises over time. On the flip side, renters don’t have to tie up a large down payment or worry about maintenance. It’s a classic short-term cost vs. long-term investment trade-off. To make an informed decision, we should consider not just the raw dollars, but also the lifestyle factors and future outlook that come with renting vs. owning in Birmingham.
.png)
Learn how Michigan property taxes and the homestead exemption affect your monthly payment.
Pros and Cons: Renting Vs. Owning a Condo in Birmingham
Financials aside, what’s it really like to rent versus own in a place like Birmingham Place? Here’s a friendly rundown, from the perspective of someone who’s seen folks on both sides of this decision:
When Renting Makes Sense
- Lower Up-Front Costs: Renting a Birmingham Place condo will typically cost you a security deposit (maybe one to one-and-a-half month’s rent) and possibly a first month’s payment up front, far less than a 20% down payment. You won’t need to tie up $60k+ of your savings just to move in. That’s huge for many young professionals or families who’d rather keep cash on hand for other goals.
- Cheaper Monthly Cash Flow: As we saw, the monthly rent can be a bit lower than the monthly cost of owning the same unit. In our example, saving a few hundred dollars each month can go toward other expenses, investments, or even fun things like enjoying dinner at your favorite Birmingham restaurant without feeling house-poor. For someone budgeting carefully, that cushion matters.
- Flexibility and Less Commitment: Not sure if downtown Birmingham is your forever spot? Renting lets you “test drive” the lifestyle. Maybe you’ll love being able to walk to the Birmingham Farmers Market on Sundays, or maybe you’ll decide you miss having a big backyard. If a job change or life change comes, a renter can relocate more easily at lease-end. Owners have to deal with selling or renting out their place if they want to move.
- Maintenance? Not Your Problem (mostly): In a condo rental, if the dishwasher breaks or the A/C acts up, you call the landlord or property manager. They handle coordinating the fix (and footing the bill). As a renter, you’re not worrying about appliance replacements, leaky pipes, or the fact that Metro Detroit’s freeze-thaw cycles might cause a roof leak, that’s on the owner or condo association to resolve. You just keep living your life.
- No Property Tax or HOA Fees: The renter isn’t directly paying property taxes or the monthly HOA fee. Of course, the rent you pay is set with those costs in mind (your landlord uses rent to cover those expenses). But if taxes go up or a special assessment is levied on the condo owners for, say, a big lobby renovation, that’s not your financial headache in the short term. Rent is typically fixed for the lease term, providing predictable costs.
On the other hand, what do you give up by renting? In a word: ownership. You won’t build equity or wealth from the home itself, and you’re subject to your landlord’s rules and the possibility of rent increases in the future. That leads us to the other side of the coin.
Get the 2025 Southeast Michigan outlook on prices, inventory, and rates.
When Owning Makes Sense
- Building Equity & Long-Term Investment: When you buy, part of your monthly payment is essentially going back into your own pocket as equity. Over a few years, you could pay down a significant chunk of your mortgage. And if Birmingham property values keep rising (as they historically have, thanks to the city’s desirability), your condo could appreciate in value. Many Birmingham homeowners have seen their properties gain value over time, for example, Birmingham’s home values more than doubled over the last decade in some cases. Instead of your money disappearing as rent, it’s working for you when you own.
- Stability and Predictability: With a fixed-rate mortgage, your principal and interest payments are locked in. While taxes and HOA fees can change, you generally won’t face the kind of sudden large increases that renters might if the market shifts. Metro Detroit renters have had it relatively calm, but in some cities rents can jump year to year. Owning your Birmingham Place condo means you won’t get a surprise notice that “rent is going up 10% next year.” You’re in control of your housing cost (aside from those incremental tax/HOA changes).
- Michigan Tax Benefits: Homeownership comes with some perks at tax time. You may deduct mortgage interest on your federal taxes (depending on current tax laws and your situation), and in Michigan, owner-occupants benefit from that homestead exemption which saves you on property taxes. Essentially, if you own and live in your Birmingham condo, you pay a lower millage rate than a landlord would. Over the years, that can save you a good chunk of money, savings a landlord might not fully pass on to a renter. It’s a little local secret that owning your primary residence in Michigan is tax-advantaged, helping tilt the scales slightly toward buying if you plan to stay put.
- Freedom to Make it Yours: When the condo is your own, you have the freedom to paint the walls your favorite color, remodel the kitchen, or swap out light fixtures to match your style. Birmingham Place units already come with high-end finishes, but as an owner you can customize as you see fit. Renters usually have to live with the decor and choices the owner made (no knocking down a wall to open the kitchen, for instance). Owning means your home truly reflects you.
- Sense of Community & Roots: There’s an intangible but real aspect to owning: the sense of putting down roots. You become a long-term neighbor, part of the Birmingham community in a deeper way. Many condo owners at Birmingham Place and around town take pride in their property and their city. You might join the condo board, get to know the other owners, and feel invested in the building’s future. If you love Birmingham, the concerts in Shain Park, the art fairs, the fact that you run into familiar faces at the local Kroger or Market, owning a home here can deepen that connection. You’re not just passing through; you’re a stakeholder in the community.
Of course, ownership isn’t all rosy: you’re responsible if something goes wrong (even in a condo, you might have to replace a faulty water heater or cover a special assessment for building repairs). There’s also the big commitment of that down payment and the pressure of a mortgage. Life can bring changes, if the market dips and you need to sell quickly, that can be stressful. Homeownership is a long game, best suited for those prepared to stay put for a number of years. As one expert advice goes, “date the rate, marry the house”, meaning, only buy if you love the home and plan to hold it long term, because you can always refinance the interest rate later when it improves, but you can’t change the price you paid for the property.
Metro Detroit Market Trends Impacting Your Decision
Your personal pros and cons are one thing, but what about the bigger picture? It helps to know what’s happening in the Metro Detroit real estate market in 2025, because those trends will affect both rent prices and the experience of owning.
- Interest Rates & Financing: As mentioned, mortgage rates spiked from their pandemic-era lows and spent much of 2024–2025 in the mid-6% to low-7% range. Lately, they’ve dipped closer to the low-6% range, giving would-be buyers a bit of relief. The expectation among many economists is that if inflation continues to ease, rates might gradually fall further. What does that mean for you? If you buy now, you might be paying a premium in interest short-term, but you could have opportunities to refinance to a lower rate in a couple of years, potentially lowering that monthly payment. If you’re renting now and waiting for rates to drop, keep an eye on the trends; you’ll want to be ready to buy when the numbers align for you. Timing the market is tough, so often the best time to buy is when you find a place you love and you can afford it.
- Home Price Trajectory: In Greater Detroit, home prices have been on the rise. Despite higher rates, the limited housing inventory and steady demand have propped up prices. Birmingham, in particular, as a walkable and affluent town, has seen strong price resilience. As of late 2025, the median price for homes in Birmingham (including houses and condos) is quite high, easily in the $800k-$900k range for single-family homes, and condos like Birmingham Place often selling from the mid-$300s upward as we noted. The double-digit appreciation of 2020-2021 has cooled, but we’re still seeing modest growth year-over-year (e.g. a few percent increase in values). If you rent, you’re sidestepping the risk of a market downturn but also potentially missing out on gains if values keep climbing. If you buy, you lock in a price now, which could look like a bargain five years from now if trends continue, or possibly a peak if the market corrects. Michigan’s market tends to be steadier than the coasts; we don’t usually see huge booms and busts, but we do see consistent growth. Even during national downturns, desirable neighborhoods like Birmingham often hold value relatively well, though nothing is guaranteed.
- Rent Trends & New Developments: On the rental side, Metro Detroit’s rents have been rising, but slowly and steadily, no crazy surges. For instance, Detroit metro area rents were up a few percent in the past year, a sign of a healthy but not wild rental market. In Birmingham, there aren’t a ton of large apartment complexes; most rentals are condos or smaller buildings. Recently, a new luxury apartment building (like the announced Birmingham Pointe development) has tested the waters with high-end rents (reports mentioned figures around $4.50 per square foot, quite steep), showing there’s demand for upscale rentals here. If more luxury rentals come to market, that could keep rent prices competitive, but given Birmingham’s limited downtown space, don’t expect an oversupply anytime soon. If anything, high demand and limited supply mean rents in prime areas will remain on the high side. For renters, that means you should budget for possible rent increases each lease renewal. For owners, a strong rental market is actually a nice safety net: if you ever needed to move, you could potentially rent out your Birmingham Place condo for a good rate to cover your costs.
- Community and Lifestyle Factors: One trend that emerged post-2020 is people valuing walkable communities and amenities. Birmingham fits that bill perfectly, which is partly why its real estate is in demand. Folks want to be able to walk to the grocery store, meet friends at the coffee shop, attend summer concerts on the park lawn, all without a long drive. This lifestyle factor means Birmingham’s housing (rentals and sales) will likely stay desirable. If you’re drawn to this way of life, consider that renting might be a short-term solution, but owning gives you a long-term claim to a spot in this coveted community. Sometimes intangible factors like “I love living here” are just as important as the dollars and cents.
In summary, the market outlook in late 2025 in Metro Detroit (and Birmingham in particular) suggests: renting is a bit easier on the wallet today, but buying secures your place in a rising market for tomorrow. The smartest move will depend on where you see yourself in a few years and how you weigh financial costs against personal priorities.
See how new luxury rentals in downtown Birmingham are pricing and why that matters for the rent-vs-buy gap.
.png)
Making the Choice: Questions to Ask Yourself
Still on the fence? That’s completely understandable, it’s a big decision. Here are a few key questions a local real estate expert would recommend you consider, almost like a mini checklist, to figure out whether renting or owning in Birmingham Place (or anywhere in Metro Detroit) is right for you:
- “How long do I plan to live here?”, If you’re just testing the waters in Birmingham or know you might move in a year or two (say, your job could transfer you), renting is probably the safer bet. However, if you’re fairly certain you’ll want to call Birmingham home for the next 5+ years, buying starts to make more sense. The longer you own, the more time you have to ride out market fluctuations, pay down the mortgage, and reap the benefits of appreciation.
- “What can I afford right now?”, Take a hard look at your budget. Do you have enough savings for a down payment and an emergency fund after that? Will your monthly housing cost as an owner leave you “house poor,” or can you comfortably cover it? If buying stretches you to the limit, it may be wiser to rent a bit longer and save up or wait for a slightly better rate. On the flip side, if you’re financially ready, owning a home in a solid market like Birmingham can be a great long-term investment.
- “Have I run the true numbers?”, Go beyond just comparing the rent check to the mortgage payment. Factor in everything: HOA fees, taxes, insurance, potential maintenance, and the equity you’d build. Sometimes seeing a five-year projection of your net costs/benefits can clarify things. For example, maybe renting saves you $500 a month now, but if your rent increases 5% each year and meanwhile by owning you’d pay down, say, $20k of your principal in five years and your property might gain value, those long-term numbers could tilt the equation. Use a rent vs. buy calculator or talk to a financial advisor if needed. As a Metro Detroit real estate agent would tell you, every case is unique.
- “What is my lifestyle and which option suits it better?”, Do you value flexibility above all, or are you craving a place to truly call your own? Some people love that as a renter, they can just submit a maintenance request and not think twice; others find themselves itching to tear up the carpet and renovate (not possible unless you own!). If you have pets, for instance, owning might give you more freedom (no landlord pet restrictions, though Birmingham Place likely has its own pet rules for all). If you have kids or are planning to, think about space and schools: Birmingham Place is in a great school district, but a two-bedroom condo might feel cramped versus renting a larger house. Your stage of life and personal preferences play a big role.
- “What do local experts say?”, It never hurts to chat with people who know the market. A local Metro Detroit realtor or financial planner who’s familiar with Birmingham can provide insight into trends they’re seeing. Maybe they’ll tell you condo inventory is very limited and buying now is wise, or conversely that renting for another year might put you in a better position. Since they’ve seen many clients make this choice, they can share real examples. (On that note, feel free to reach out to a Birmingham real estate professional you trust, sometimes just talking it through with someone who understands the numbers and the neighborhood can be incredibly clarifying.
Finding What’s Right for You in Birmingham
At the end of the day, “Is renting cheaper than owning?” is a simple question with a not-so-simple answer. In pure dollars and cents today, renting a Birmingham Place condo is indeed cheaper on a monthly basis than buying one. The gap isn’t enormous, but it’s noticeable in 2025. However, “cheaper” can depend on your timeframe. Renting may save you money in the short run and offer valuable flexibility. Owning can potentially save or even earn you money in the long run through equity, and it offers the priceless feeling of having a home that’s truly yours.
For Metro Detroiters, and especially in a beloved community like Birmingham, the decision often comes down to personal circumstances. There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. You might prioritize financial flexibility and mobility, making renting the smart choice for now. Or you might prioritize stability and investment in your future, leaning toward buying despite the higher monthly cost. Both paths have merit.
The good news? Birmingham is a fantastic place to live, whether you rent or own. You’re still going to enjoy those summer art fairs, holiday tree lightings, evenings at the Emagine Palladium theater, and Sunday mornings sipping coffee on your balcony overlooking downtown. The key is doing what lets you enjoy those moments with peace of mind.
If you’re still torn, consider reaching out for local expert advice. Chat with a trusted real estate professional who knows the Birmingham market inside-out, someone who can look at your individual situation and help you weigh the pros and cons one-on-one. Sometimes a quick conversation about current condo prices, interest rate forecasts, or even alternative options (like maybe a rent-to-own scenario or looking at a different neighborhood) can illuminate the best path forward.
Bottom line: Whether you choose to rent that chic Birmingham Place condo or buy it and make it your own, you’re making a home in one of Metro Detroit’s most special corners. And with the right preparation and guidance, you can feel confident you’ve made the choice that’s best for you and your family. Here’s to finding your perfect place in Birmingham, and maybe we’ll see you around town, enjoying all the local treasures this community has to offer!
Thinking about your next steps in Birmingham? Don’t hesitate to connect with a local real estate expert who can answer questions and offer personalized guidance. Whether you’re exploring rentals or ready to house-hunt, having an experienced Metro Detroit professional by your side makes all the difference. Happy homefinding!
DON'T KEEP US A SECRET - SHARE WITH A FRIEND OR ON SOCIAL MEDIA!
THINKING OF MOVING TO Metro Detroit, OR LOOKING TO RELOCATE IN THE AREA? VIEW A LIST OF CURRENT HOMES FOR SALE BELOW.
Metro Detroit Homes for Sale
The Perna Team and Michael Perna are the best real estate agents in Metro Detroit and Ann Arbor. The Perna Team and Michael Perna have been hired as a real estate agent by hundreds of home owners to sell their homes in Metro Detroit and Ann Arbor.
The Perna Team were steady, responsive, and genuinely supportive from beginning to end. If you're buying or selling a home anywhere in Metro Detroit, Noah is the kind of agent who shows up with professionalism, care, and your best interest at heart.
Posted by Michael Perna on
Leave A Comment